Orlando Real Estate Insights

Homes Near Private Schools in Orlando: What Families Need to Know

Published October 1, 2025 by Ted Moseley · 12 min read

Quick Summary: Orlando is home to some of Florida’s most prestigious private schools including Lake Highland Prep, Trinity Prep, The First Academy, Bishop Moore, Master’s Academy, Montverde Academy, and The Geneva School. Families moving to Central Florida often look for homes near these schools—whether historic estates in Winter Park or new builds in Lake Nona. Expect premium pricing, strong resale value, and communities shaped by education.

Why Families Prioritize Homes Near Private Schools

For many relocating families, choosing the right school is just as important as square footage. Orlando’s private schools are nationally recognized for their academics, athletics, faith-based programs, and arts. Homes close to these schools often carry higher values because buyers are investing in both real estate and their children’s futures. Living near a top school also connects families with like-minded communities focused on education and lifestyle.

Top Private & Religious Schools in Orlando

Lake Highland Preparatory School (Downtown Orlando)

Lake Highland Prep offers a 42-acre campus just outside downtown Orlando. Known for rigorous academics, award-winning robotics and debate, and strong athletic pipelines, it’s one of Florida’s most competitive schools. Families often seek homes in Baldwin Park, Colonialtown, and Thornton Park.

Trinity Preparatory School (Winter Park)

A grade 6–12 prep school sending many graduates to Ivy League universities. Trinity Prep balances academics, athletics, and arts. Nearby neighborhoods include Winter Park, Maitland, and Casselberry.

The First Academy (Southwest Orlando)

Affiliated with First Baptist Orlando, TFA is known for its Christian values, STEM programs, and athletics. Families often live in Dr. Phillips, Windermere, and MetroWest.

Bishop Moore Catholic High School (College Park)

Bishop Moore combines academics and athletics in a faith-based environment. College Park offers a mix of bungalows and modern infill homes within minutes of downtown.

Master’s Academy (Oviedo)

This K–12 Christian school appeals to families in Oviedo, Winter Springs, and Chuluota. Many buyers in the area value larger lots and no-HOA flexibility.

Montverde Academy (Lake County)

Known worldwide for its elite basketball program and international student body, Montverde attracts families relocating from abroad. Many purchase in Clermont or luxury lakefront homes in Windermere.

The Geneva School (Casselberry)

Offering a classical Christian curriculum focused on humanities, rhetoric, and philosophy. Families often live in Maitland, Altamonte Springs, or Winter Springs.

Best Neighborhoods Near Top Private Schools

Winter Park

Blending historic homes and cultural amenities, Winter Park is close to Lake Highland and Trinity Prep. Homes typically start around $800K, with estates surpassing $2M.

College Park

Adjacent to Bishop Moore Catholic. Features 1920s bungalows, modern infill homes, and dining. Homes range $500K–$1.2M.

Windermere & Dr. Phillips

Lakefront estates and golf course communities near The First Academy. Luxury homes often exceed $1M.

Oviedo

Family-friendly city with private options like Master’s Academy. Homes range $450K–$800K, many with no HOA.

Pros & Cons of Living Near Orlando’s Top Schools

Pros

Access to nationally ranked private education
Higher resale values and long-term demand
Strong community ties with families of similar goals
Convenience for extracurriculars and after-school activities

Cons

Premium pricing compared to other areas
Traffic congestion during school hours
Limited privacy for homes next to campuses

Real Client Stories

A relocating tech executive from California purchased in Windermere specifically for The First Academy’s athletic program. A family from New York chose Winter Park to access Lake Highland Prep while enjoying its cultural scene. A military family moving from overseas selected Oviedo for affordability and proximity to Master’s Academy.